Tires Pirelli or BFGoodrich

PartReview Score

Rank #7 in ranking

1194

618

127

220

967

3.6

Grip

3.7

Noise

3.6

Ride comfort

3.5

Owners' choice:

PR Score

Ranking

Votes

Reviews

Average rating

Properties

Car

PartReview Score

Rank #16 in ranking

552

238

334

3.8

Grip

4.0

Noise

3.4

Ride comfort

3.4

Owners' choice:

Reviews

All

Pirelli

BFGoodrich

BFGoodrich › Tires

shindig34 25 Oct 2025, 15:03

Grip:

Rating 5.0

BFGoodrich all terrain tires have been my go to as we have them on our jeep right now (which we are not keeping much longer).

Pros: reliable choice

BFGoodrich › Tires

Magnum_ripple 24 Oct 2025, 23:08

Rating 5.0

The 275/70/17 size shouldn’t rub with stock suspension, my bfg ko2’s never did and now I have ko3’s and they don’t.

Pros: no rubbing with stock suspension

Pirelli › Tires

Glacier98777 24 Oct 2025, 08:17

Ride comfort:

Rating 5.0

I did take my run flats off and replace with pirelli p zeros all round and it's made such a difference to the ride quality.

Pros: improved ride quality

Vehicle: BMW

Pirelli › Tires

DetectiveVinc 24 Oct 2025, 08:01

Grip:
Ride comfort:

Rating 4.0

Der beste Allrounder, fährt sich aber schneller runter.

Pros: bester Allrounder

Cons: fährt sich schneller runter

Pirelli › Tires

jones5112 24 Oct 2025, 02:33

Grip:
Noise:

Rating 5.0

I bought pirelli scorpions at2 on my Amarok

They are awesome, quiet on the highway and heaps of grip on and off road

Pros: quiet on highway, heaps of grip

Vehicle: Volkswagen Amarok

BFGoodrich › Tires

CStreeterdit 24 Oct 2025, 00:31

Grip:

Rating 5.0

I personally love my BFG tires, and have had a good experience with multiple sets.

Pros: good experience, multiple sets

Pirelli › Tires

upironsXL 17 Oct 2024, 18:39

Noise:

Rating 3.0

Replacing mine tomorrow with Pirelli scorpion Weatheractives. Tires are fine but I need a more versatile tire for winter and I'm hoping they will help with the road noise too.

Pros: versatile tire for winter

Cons: road noise

Pirelli › Tires

rick_rickman 1 Oct 2024, 14:13

Ride comfort:

Rating 3.0

I just replaced my pirellis after 19k. Hope the michelins hold up as long or longer.

Pros: null

Cons: replaced after 19k

Mileage: 19000 km

Pirelli › Tires

Thiscatmcnern 20 Feb 2025, 16:22

Grip:

Rating 1.0

Absolute garbage, they only lasted 20k miles on my XC90 T8. Pretty bad in wet conditions also.

Cons: absolute garbage, bad in wet

Vehicle: Volvo XC90

Mileage: 20000 km

Pirelli › Tires

EnSabahNurZ 20 Feb 2025, 15:48

Grip:

Rating 1.0

Verdes suck. As others are saying, 3 peak tires are the way to go if you’re gonna deal with snow and don’t want dedicated snow tires. I’ve switched to scorpion weatheractive and my last two trips to Tahoe in heavy snow have been a breeze.

Pros: breeze in heavy snow

Cons: Verdes suck