Tires MICHELIN or Goodyear

Michelin X-Ice was my go to for my 14’s on my AW.

Have dws06 on our s4. Great tire so far. Comfortable and quiet compared to the Michelin as4 they replaced

I got Michelin Defender 225/65R16 and they are great tires. Got them at discount tire and they are not cheap, but worth it IMO

I would choose Michelin AS4s over the Contis if they're available and in your price range. They offer better MPG and ride comfort over the Contis while delivering more grip in the wet and dry. Just an all around better tire, but the Conti is still great albeit a little heavier than Michelin.

Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady all day long. Have these on all our SUVs.

I replaced the stock ones on my 21 (@ 35k) with Michelin CC2’s a few weeks ago. My fuel mileage went down by a few MPG but the ride is much smoother and quieter. And I tested them out in the snow and ice today. Well worth the extra money!

Just installed these on my MYP, and I freaking love them. I got 43k on the Michelins, granted I probably went 5k over.

Just drove through a storm and just had Michilen cross climate 2's put on. Both worked amazing.

Another vote for Michelin Pilot A/S 4. I had them on my 2016 Mazda6. They were quiet and decently grippy for a non-sport all season tire. I hate them. They’re not as noisy as the OE Dunlops on the 2016 but when cornering they’re like driving on mush.

The stock Goodyear wranglers are shitty tires. I had 4 flats in 6 months with them. And ride quality/handling wasn’t great. But I’m a cheap ass and got 30k miles out of them.

I’ve only purchased Michelin for many years now. When my stock wranglers looked similar to OP’s photo, I put Michelin LTX M/S on and never worried about tires again - until this week.

70,000 miles later and the Michelins are finally at the end of their journey- going to replace them with Michelin Defender LTX since the M/S line is discontinued