Tires Toyo or Pirelli

Our XC90 just got fitted with Pirelli scorpions... Smooth as butter.

I mostly have stuck with Pirelli Scorpions and have been very happy. The Pirelli Scorpion Verde model gets a bit better gas mileage and is quiet.

Toyo's are the best tire I've ever had. They balance well, don't cup, are quiet by AT tire standards, and are great in rain and snow.

I had the Toyo's on my truck. Wear was good, road noise very minimal. Great tire on road and off road.

I have had the Toyo's on my 2016 for 2 years now and am really happy with them. They do really good in the Canadian snow, and are not super loud with the doors off on the highway. The only issue I have with them is that in some cool and wet mornings, I have to slow down on some corners or the slide a bit.

I have them but a different size. No complaints, smooth, relatively quiet. the Toyo is the more road oriented of the three, and in my case, notably lighter. But I have also taken it to Moab and through some snow wheeling and they’ve been good.

Currently using toyo TR1, quite noisy when cruising on highway since it's considered as UHP

I did get one used and it seemed to hold up just ok until I ran over a small branch at 35 mph. The thread peeled from the tire body from the inner area outwards, slowly leaking air.

Even expensive tires can be cheap sometimes depending on how they were manufactured. I got a soft tire once and it wore the treads down super fast on just one tire. I rotated them multiple times and it was always the same tire wearing down.

It was a Toyo Geomancer, the tires were fine and looked nice but that one tire was definitely defective.

I just swapped Pirelli Scorpions that came on my Edge for Geolanders. The scorps only had 35k on them and were cupped with sidewall belts showing.