Tires Pirelli or Tesla

I have the Scorpions and love them. I choose them because of the lower ride noise and think they look nicer on the car than the CC2s.

Pirelli scorpion AS/3. Quieter, softer and better handling than original shit Toyo’s. Source: 5k miles on them so far.

Got the Pirelli Scorpion AS Plus 3 from DiscountTire. 40min for the whole thing and wow never knew my car can drive so smooth. I can feel that it’s grippy as well.

So happy with them thus far. On regular drives, they're so much quieter and feel less harsh than the stock Hankooks. In the canyons, I'm really happy with the handling.

I have been impressed with the Pirelli Scorpio and Sam's Club most of the time have them on sale. I don't have a Mazda yet but on my Atlas they have been better than the OEM Khumo and the previous set of Michelin I had. Smooth ride, quiet and great in wet and snowy conditions.

Scorps in the winter are fine, not great, and terrible at anything backcountry related that isn’t dry.

Pirelli are fine. I think they get bad rep but worked well even in light snow and rain.

I have had experiences with many tires models on CX-5, my shop basically agreed Scorpion has to be one of the worst tires to recommend to customer for all the reasons you mentioned. These tires has worse road feel than even Westlakes

My initial PZeros have a tire bulge at 13k. I think they were 80% down anyhow.

our stock Pirelli’s got damage and worn very early and set had to be replaced at 11k. Not pleased