Tires Pirelli or Goodyear

I run the Pirelli on my B9.5 S4 and no complains so far, heading into first full winter together so I'll see how it goes.

I like Pirelli ice zero fr, they have the best grip, Bridgestone also fine

The tires are good, BTW. I had them on my old car and was going in circles around others who apparently cheaped out on their tires. Like, had to help get a 4WD pick-up truck out of a ditch at one point.

I ran some good year winter tires for 8 winters before without issue.

Pirelli WeatherActive

Today I will get Pirelli runflat because sounds like it has better thread wear than continental .

I have a 22 and the pirellis were awesome at first but definitely did not last. There’s a reason they have no manufacturer warranty. They are performance tires. Rubber is soft and wears faster.

I've had the P7s and Continentals on my 2010 Mercury Milan and 2007 Subaru Forester. The Continentals were better on the Milan, the Pirellis were better on the Forester.

Absolute garbage, they only lasted 20k miles on my XC90 T8. Pretty bad in wet conditions also.

Verdes suck. As others are saying, 3 peak tires are the way to go if you’re gonna deal with snow and don’t want dedicated snow tires. I’ve switched to scorpion weatheractive and my last two trips to Tahoe in heavy snow have been a breeze.