Battery Panasonic or Tesla

Tesla Battery
Gforce1
  • Indicator:
Rating 4.0

If I could easily repurpose the cells in my 140k mile Model 3 into home storage for my solar I would rather do that than sell the car. 3% degradation the car itself needed more work than a replacement battery ever would have cost.

Pros: minor battery degradation
Cons: car needed more work
Mileage: 140000 km
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Panasonic Battery
CycleChris2
  • Indicator:
Rating 4.0

Yeah, the oem Panasonic battery is easy to kill. I replaced mine (2022 Turbo) with an AGM type. Most all batteries are made by Johnson Controls, under different names. The cheapest price I found was $179 with a 4 year warranty at Walmart. Everstart Platinum group 35. Was a 10 min job to remove and replace. They can even test your old one. The agm type is in the deep cycle family, it can be discharged quite a bit without any issues, the stock battery (flooded acid type) is easy to damage.

Pros: AGM type, deep cycle
Cons: OEM battery easy to kill
Vehicle: Mazda
Part number: GROUP 35
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Panasonic Battery
Leafs799
  • Cranking:
Rating 5.0

My 2019 Mazda 3 died on me randomly a couple months ago. The dealership ran a test on it and it came out fine. I changed it anyway as it was a stock 5 year old battery. It’s been fine since, even in the -20°C temps where I am.

Pros: fine even in cold
Vehicle: Mazda 3
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Panasonic Battery

I just replaced the battery on my eco drive from maybe 2008ish? Battery itself was 14 bucks on ebay, oem brand(Panasonic). Swap took 5 minutes.

Pros: easy swap, oem brand
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Tesla Battery

Tesla on nmc battery drops around 10% after 8 or 10 years (can't remember exactly) from what I read. But lfp battery is inherently able to have longer life span and charge cycles. On top of inherently having ability to be safer / less explodey.

Pros: longer life span, safer
Cons: 10% drop after years
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Tesla Battery

For context, I have a first generation Tesla Model S - 2014. It has 215,000-ish miles on it. The battery capacity has gone down by about 10-12%. It still runs and drives like a dream. It's on the original battery.

Pros: runs and drives great
Cons: battery capacity decreased
Mileage: 346000 km
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Tesla Battery

I have an early VIN 2020 MYP with 80,000 km; the diagnostic says 87%, so 13% drop in battery health. Range calculation at 100% SOC dropped 4.9%.

Pros: diagnostic says 87%
Cons: 13% drop in health
Mileage: 80000 km
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Tesla Battery

I don't want someone else's crusty ass battery. Charge times are already low and are plentiful (Tesla at least), I don't see the utility of swapping the battery out when I could stop for like 15 mins.

Pros: charge times are low
Cons: unnecessary complication
Vehicle: Porsche
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Tesla Battery
fr3d0511
  • Indicator:
Rating 1.0

Yes. Mine was from 2020 and quit without warning March of this year. Contrary to what some people have said, the car won\u2019t always warn you that the battery is weak.

Cons: quit without warning
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Tesla Battery
pw5a29
  • Indicator:
Rating 1.0

Yes, my 2021 battery died mid 2024. No warnings, no abnormal behaviour. Luckily it was still under warranty and the towing and repairing were free.

Pros: towing and repairing free
Cons: no abnormal behaviour
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Write your review

Help others - share your experience with this part.

Other comparisons
Loading...