Windshield Pilkington or OEM Volkswagen

Pilkington Windshield

I'm going to put this the best way I can....... I am a glass guy, and yes, I own a '16 GTI. I can tell you first hand that the glass in our cars is not perfect. However, I will also tell you that it is very difficult to keep curved glass free of distortion...With regards to the aftermarket, I would recommend Sekurit and Pilkington for our VWs, as they provide VW with a lot of OE product. So, the guidelines for production should be identical.

Pros: guidelines for production identical
Cons: difficult to keep free of distortion
Vehicle: Volkswagen
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
OEM Volkswagen Windshield
cky3396
  • Clarity:
Rating 4.0

got the windshield replaced today at safelite and everything went well...go with VW - its really not much more expensive. ensure that the camera/rain sensor details show up with the glass version. this glass comes equip with the glass-side hardware pre-installed that allows for the interior camera housing and trim to fasten/lock into it.

Pros: glass-side hardware pre-installed
Cons: potential damage
Vehicle: Volkswagen Golf
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Pilkington Windshield
tomyabo42
  • Clarity:
  • Chips/cracks:
Rating 5.0

I had Safelite do replacements on my car as well as my husband's car. Of course the insurance wouldn't cover OEM (had eSurance at the time) but I heard that the aftermarket glass that Safelite uses on these cars (Pilkington I think but spelling could be wrong) is an OEM supplier for a lot of German brands. It's been a few years now and both cars aren't showing any issues with the replacement glass. We both have '11 Golf TDIs. FWIW, the replacement glass on our cars also had the tint strip along the top and mirror area in the same place as the OEM glass, you really can't tell the difference unless you look at the manufacturer's stamp.

Pros: no issues, indistinguishable from OEM, tint strip matches
Vehicle: Volkswagen Golf
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
OEM Volkswagen Windshield
thenew3
  • Chips/cracks:
Rating 2.0

The OEM windshields are very weak and prone to rock chips. My 07 3.6 4motion wagon got several chips within the first year of owning it. my 08 3.6 4motion wagon also got a chip within the first month of owning it. My BMW 328i have been hit harder (i.e. going faster speeds) and never had a chip. the shop that patched both of my wagons up said they work on many vw's with chips. They say VW uses a thinner glass to lower the weight, thus causing it to chip easier.

Cons: very weak, prone to chips, thinner glass
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Pilkington Windshield
gtaylor0
  • Clarity:
  • Chips/cracks:
Rating 1.0

My experience with the installation I had last year to replace a cracked windshield and the national company mentioned in this thread: --Installer left a noticeably huge gap between windshield and roofline; installed it too low --Installer left a gap in the glue around the edge. Consequently, water leaked into the cabin from the map lights when backing up --After complaining and another attempt, reinstaller used way too much glue and was sloppy, to the point where it smeared on part of the A pillar fabric on both sides

Cons: huge gap, water leaked
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
1 ... 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26

Write your review

Help others - share your experience with this part.

Other comparisons
Loading...