Tires Vredestein or OEM Porsche

I have had the Quatrac 5 on my car for a few years without issue.

I haven’t had those but have been running a set of Quatrac Pros for the past three and a half years. They have been good tires. No complaints from me after nearly 44k miles.

I'm very pleased with the Vredestein Hypertrac all-season tires

I'm very happy with my Vredestein Quatrac Pro tires. They're an All-Weather tire that splits the difference between an all-season and winter tire. They can handle all temps, but are 3 mountain peak certified for winter weather. They're quiet, comfortable, and competent.

Got Vredensteins on an older honda. They are great -- track well in the wet and muck and good handling all around.

I had a positive experience with Vredestein! They performed really well in both wet and dry conditions, and the handling was super precise. What surprised me the most was how evenly they wore.

I have vredensteins on my 2011 c300. They have about 20,000 miles on them and are still pretty decent. They have been awesome in the snow and rain this winter and were pretty awesome in the summer. I've probably got another 10,000 miles of wear, which is awesome for this car.

I put the Quatrac Pro tires on our Model Y about 8,000 miles ago and have been very happy with them. No noticeable difference in road noise, basically no efficiency difference, but much better grip in wet and slick conditions.

I recently bought a ‘16 with 6,500 miles. Most everything checked out but the tires were original and dry rotted to hell.

I have Costco's version of the Michelin Defender 2 (X Tour 2) on our Atlas and they have been great. I have also used a set of Vredestein Hitrac A/S, they're a great tire until the last half of the treat and they get absolutely rock hard and you may as well be on ice. I just replaced a set with plenty of usable tread left because they had suck little traction. Overall, I would suggest a Defender LTX M/S.