Tires Toyo or YOKOHAMA

Toyo Open Country are the only tires I have run for the last 20+years. Across three 4Runners. Close to 500k miles between my ‘98 SR5, ‘05Limited and 2020 ORP. I live in Washington and do quite a bit more off roading than it sounds like you do. The Open County Toyo line has been fantastic off-road, but I love them because they are so quiet and comfortable on the highway for such a capable tire.

I commute to DIA from the Springs a LOT, and I have the AT3s. Great tire, lightweight enough to preserve MPGs, but still does well in snow. Plus they still look pretty good. Had them 20k miles now and they're still in great shape.

I replaced all four with Yokohama Advent Ascends. These have been completely trouble free for the last 15,000 miles (24,000 km). I have not measured, but I'd bet I still have 8 or 9/32 left on all four. I expect them to last at least another 30,000 miles (49,000 km).

which were heaps better, noticeably a level above the bridgestones, but did cost a bit more.

They are amazing, even in the pouring rain they grip just fine, and when warmed up they dont miss a beat

Toyo opencountry CTs all day I have 100,000 on my current set and still will last another summer, they are definitely in the upper end of price but they last and they are great in the snow/ice

We also replaced with the Yokohamas and think the car rides better and is smoother at highway speeds.

Just my opinion. I run Yokohama tires on my pickup. 2nd set. Awesome! I pull 18wheeelers out of mud, drive on terrible lease roads and they holdup great.

I can't tell you what to get (not enough time on my Yokohama Geolander X-CV to make an assessment on wear but so far they handle well) but I can tell you what NOT to get. Avoid the Allenzas at all costs.

Wrangles sucked. The Yokohama was a nice tire but did not last.