Tires Toyo or Pirelli

I noticed considerably less road noise with the Scorpions compared with the Toyos that came with the car

Getting 40k miles from your OEM Toyos is pretty good. I kinda wanted to put more Toyo A36 on them as I liked how they felt but they dont have a mileage rating.

I've run the AT3's for the last three years and love them. Better than KO2's, Dura's, and Ridgegrapplers that i've run. All in 35', DD JKU. I'm in CO, so snow, rain, mud and weekend wheeling. They are the best all around. The GY are the best in the snow, but the Toyo's are a close second. I do feel like they won't have the mileage of either the Dura's or the KO2's. Only downside I see.

I'm happy with my Open Country AT3's (265/75R16's). Performance is good for my needs. I don't love them in the rain, but don't find them worse than the other A/T's I've tried. They did start getting loud around 20,000 miles but not annoyingly so.

Had them for a couple years on my truck, 285 75/16s fairly quiet in comparison to my buddies Chinese ATs. Pretty good in snow, wet traction could be better, but they’re quite good off-road. Better than the Firestones and Hankooks Iv had before for sure.

The larger tires are noticeably louder than the OEM but I haven't tried other brands to make a definitive conclusion. Performance wise I think they have been good, running through sand, gravel, pavement, rain, rocks, and snow.

The Toyos are a really decent tire, and fairly quiet for what they are.

In my experience, P-Zeros were great at first, but got slippery really fast, even when there was plenty of tread-depth left.

I have the crappy toyo tires and am actually shopping around for better tires.

Mine came from Berlin with PZeros (my M3LR had Pilot sports 4S´es) liked the michelin much more, Pzero is a garbage tire.

But it is decent, not a lot of roadnoise, so that is key.