Tires Toyo or Goodyear

I liked mine A LOT. If you don't need to snow rating, see if you can find the AT 2 version as they're usually cheaper and carry the same tread warranty.

The GY Wrangler HT has been fantastic for my ‘12 Coyote

I personally went with C load with the Toyo AT’s. Came from BFG AT E load. No regrets. Not apples to apples, but between those two the Toyo in C was SIGNIFICANTLY softer in ride quality which was comfy both on and off road. Made daily commuting, long road trips, and off roading (especially on washboard) much more tolerable.

Late to the party, but I’m 50k into my 215/75r15s and either going with toyos again in 225/75 or falken wildpeaks. I’ve been very happy with the toyos in CO weather and dry backcountry. Not a ton of mud experience to help you with but the toyos have been GREAT on everything! Road noise it so be expected with AT tires but the toyos were/are not very noisy at all.

The 3s are a little louder but nothing too noticeable unless you commute in silence. They look great and perform just as great in any weather condition, asphalt or not.

Eagle RS-A great tires for my ride, police use them.

I’m satisfied with the Goodyears I have. Goodyear efficient grip performance 2 tires I use on my Prius in the summer and in the winter I run the Goodyear ultra grip ice wrt. Which is not bad for the price.

Goodyear exhilarates are the quietest ones I've had, also the only ones I had to replace because of a wall bubble.

I've had the all seasons and they are not the greatest, tread life not great (had to get mine replaced under warranty) and they were loud.

Wild peaks> I have had a few sets of duratracs and for off-roading they have performed the least desirably in all terrain (no pun intended) snow/mud they gunk up and slide super easily, sand, I would have to drop to 8-9psi to get the same effect of going down to my normal 14psi in sand. Rock, not much of an opinion here I had these on a Colorado so it diddnt see much rock crawl if any at all. And the road noise is super loud and they wear super fast and uneven.