Tires Pirelli or MRF

I use Pirelli Weatheractives and they are an all weather tires (not all season, all weather) and work great and I'm in MB. Our winters are worse than yours and the tires were fine.

I replaced toyos at the same mileage with the same Pirellis. Huge difference in handling, I was shitting diamonds with Toyos on wet roads in heavy rain. They hydroplaned like crazy. I have put 65k on Pirellis by now and still have some life in them, probably another 10k. Great tires. And they were less noisy than toyos at least in the beginning.

I also bought the Pirelli Scorpions. Well done, great tires, so much better than the stock Toyos.

Have the same Pirelli's

They are exponentially better than those stock Toyo tires

I noticed considerably less road noise with the Scorpions compared with the Toyos that came with the car

Have done about 200 miles on the Pirellis, and the difference is night and day with everything. Noise, grip, stopping, etc...

The Pirellis are an excellent tire . Great in the rain and snow plus handle very well in all weather.

I’ve got Scorpions on my X5 and they’re O K.. but don’t have a super aggressive tread and I think the weathepeaks will be better in the snow. Plus the Scorpions haven’t been wearing great. I’ve got 30k on them and I don’t see them making it to the 60k warranty

My pirellis handled well but God was their longevity shite Pretty much cooked by 20,000ks All other tyres gave me 60,000+

A pirelli is the only tire that tried to kill me by flying off the bead on the rim and passing me on I-95. I also hated the Pirelli P zeros on both my Audis and was extremely excited when they wore out after 18k miles so I could replace them with Michelins.