Tires Pirelli or Goodyear

PartReview Score

Rank #7 in ranking

1194

618

127

220

967

3.6

Grip

3.7

Noise

3.6

Ride comfort

3.5

Owners' choice:

PR Score

Ranking

Votes

Reviews

Average rating

Properties

Car

PartReview Score

Rank #9 in ranking

1080

506

146

736

3.7

Grip

3.7

Noise

3.3

Ride comfort

3.5

Owners' choice:

Reviews

All

Pirelli

Goodyear

Pirelli › Tires

Illustrious_Salad918 17 Jan 2026, 15:17

Noise:
Ride comfort:

Rating 4.0

I have Pirelli Cinturato P7 A/S run-flats on my '21 X3 xDrive (same size) and had them on E90 as well for past several years. They do quite well in E WA winters, quiet and smooth.

Pros: quiet and smooth

Vehicle: BMW X3

Pirelli › Tires

ktatsanon 17 Jan 2026, 14:33

Grip:

Rating 4.0

Pirelli WeatherActive would be worth looking into.

Pirelli › Tires

gelomon 17 Jan 2026, 14:18

Grip:

Rating 5.0

I saved up to buy a pirelli for peace of mind

Pros: peace of mind

Goodyear › Tires

gruss72 17 Jan 2026, 02:26

Grip:

Rating 4.0

Goodyear WeatherReadys are pretty good for all year. If you live on the western side of the state you might want some dedicated snow tires.

Pros: pretty good for all year

Pirelli › Tires

ThePurpleBall 17 Jan 2026, 02:04

Grip:

Rating 5.0

Pirelli AS plus 3s. Fantastic all season tire, over here on LI and it\u2019s been 2 winters now on them. Like them more than the pilot sports or the contis

Pros: fantastic all season tire

Pirelli › Tires

RLBeau1964 29 Dec 2025, 21:31

Rating 3.0

You got 40,000 miles from a set of Pirelli tires? I’ve never hard good lucky with that brand.

Cons: never had good luck

Mileage: 48000 km

Pirelli › Tires

SteazGaming 26 Dec 2025, 22:30

Grip:

Rating 3.0

17k miles no problems, only thing is the OEM pirellis (if you get the 22s) will only last 15-20k miles with some spicier driving.

Cons: short life with spicier driving

Mileage: 17000 km

Goodyear › Tires

brazucadomundo 4 Dec 2025, 11:58

Noise:

Rating 1.0

I got Goodyear Reliants and absolutely regretted. By far the loudest tires I've ever had.

Cons: loudest tires

Pirelli › Tires

Naivirs1r 4 Dec 2025, 08:14

Noise:
Ride comfort:

Rating 2.0

if you have R1S with original pirellis tires over 10/15k miles - getting new tires will make a HUGE difference in ride quality - this is the consensus in the forums - the factory tires don't last and it makes rivian ride rough and loud sooner than most of us are used to.

Pros: huge difference in ride

Cons: don't last, rough, loud

Mileage: 12500 km