Tires OEM BMW or Goodyear

Passat Alltrack 2021, Goodyear Ultragrip Ice 2. Sweden

I've never regretted buying the best tires I can afford. Often Michelin and Goodyear, but sometimes others too.

Michelin X-Ice if you can afford them, otherwise I swear by the Goodyear Nordics as the best affordable option and even what I prefer myself over the X-Ice.

I had Duratracs on my Tacomas when I lived in the Denver area. They were reliable on and off road and handled well in all conditions. They were a little noisy when they wore down, but what 33's arent'?

More: Goodyear Eagle Sport tires @ 60K. These are the best overall tires I've ever had. Put them on my Beetle too.

Goodyear ultra grip, it’s an expensive snow, but damn near the best on my Subaru

On my GTI, I had a set of the Goodyear Eagle Exhilarate. Those were very nice tires. Not too loud, especially for a performance all-season, but very grippy and responsive.

Noisier than my KO2s, but not unbearably so.

My experience with Goodyear is that they are trash.

I bought tires from walmart exactly once. One developed a big bulge in the sidewall after a couple days, one didn't hold air, one had a knock, and they fucked up the weight placement on one so it was hitting my caliper. Never again.