Tires Firestone or Goodyear

I have been impressed with the Firestone Destinations. They came on the new Jeep Cherokees. Liked them enough to replace with the Destination AT2 on my Cherokee and also my Tacoma. Good balanced all terrain tire.

I own a set of Firestone indy 500's that I inherited, and I really like the good grip and predictable slip plus the even wear and low noise. Definitely going to order another set

On Tuesday, I had new tires put on the car. Nothing special, some goodyear assurance all seasons. The new tires made a big difference in ride quality and handling.

Prefer the Firestone's, however, since they're surprisingly quiet.

Goodyear Eagle Sport All-Seasons.

I enjoy more spirited driving which sometimes does involve sliding the car a little. However for daily use, they're pretty quiet and are pretty good on tread wear.

I made it just shy of 60k. Now I have Coopers. The Good Years were way better in ice and snow.

It’ll probably be close to 50K on the Firestone Destinations that came on my ‘21 Sport DCLB, great tires.

I have since transitioned to a set of Goodyear Wrangler A/Ts (275/60/20) for the past year and a half.

The best I’ve gotten was shy over 19 MPG (19.3-19.5) but average 17-18 MPG highway, same speeds 65-70 MPH.

City is around 14-16 on average.

The stock Goodyear wranglers are shitty tires. I had 4 flats in 6 months with them. And ride quality/handling wasn’t great. But I’m a cheap ass and got 30k miles out of them.

I’ve only purchased Michelin for many years now. When my stock wranglers looked similar to OP’s photo, I put Michelin LTX M/S on and never worried about tires again - until this week.

70,000 miles later and the Michelins are finally at the end of their journey- going to replace them with Michelin Defender LTX since the M/S line is discontinued

The wranglers on my 2016 were past the wear bars bald, completely slick, by 29K miles. They single-handedly guaranteed I’d never have another set of Goodyears for as long as I live.