Tires BFGoodrich or Goodyear

We run Falken Wilkpeak A/T3W on my wife’s Yukon and they are great. I had BF Goodrich A/T KO2s on my previous pickup and they were pretty good too. I’ve never owned Toyo tires before, so it’s a bit of a leap of faith, but the preliminary reviews I’m reading about the quality and efficiency of these EV specific all-terrains is promising. They look great!

Recently purchased two Goodyear RSA from Walmart that were in sale. So far so good. The ride is nice and comfortable.

I’m a KO2 guy though. Off-road performance is unreal. The 10-ply are nearly indestructible. They drive great and mine have always stayed quiet(I know other people haven’t had that experience).

Downside of a KO2 10 ply is they are heavy and sap fuel economy.

KO2s for me have been excellent. They are quieter than the stock Goodyears for me, ride a little better and a ton more capable. Plus after 20k miles they aren’t showing any wear and only down 1/32nd so by that math they’re going to last a very long time.

I took a 1mpg hit going to them but that’s expected.

Bfg KO2s did well for the 4 years I've had them and we had the freezes with iced roads the last 2 years.

Just ditched the OEM set of Goodyears on our Atlas this weekend for a set of Michelins, do it. Don't let tires hold back enjoyment of a vehicle.

If you have a Walmart, Goodyear Reliant tires. They are Goodyear's Walmart exclusive tire. I have run about 5k on mine and so far, so good. Quiet, good grip, solid warranty. Better than my original tires that csme eith my car new.

Tires I've run that have been trouble-free: Goodyear, Michelin, Toyo, BF Goodrich, Bridgestone, and Firestone.

Tires that have failed me catastrophically: Kelly, Continental, Uniroyal, and General.

While I was originally happy with the GoodYear Assurance Comfortdrives two years ago on the HL, in the short 28K miles I've put on them, they have become quite loud and wearing rather quickly.

The BF Goodrich MT/TA 255/75 R17 are the original tires on my JEEP Wrangler Unlimited Rubicon Hard Rock which has only 24,000 easy miles on it. I have never been off road. At 24k miles they are badly worn and cupping and the noise has become unbearable.