Brake discs Zimmermann or R1 Concepts

Had the same dilemma a few weeks back. Went with Zimmermann drilled rotors paired with EBC red. So far I've been pleased with them.

Brakes are doing great.

I just recently did the back brakes at 37k and the fronts last weekend at 39k on my 2020 M340i. Dealer said rotors were at min thickness last June but I waited for the sensors to actually trip and even then I got 1k+ miles with a good bit of pad life left still. Went with Zimmerman rotors and OEM pads from FCP Euro and second that combo. I read too many hit or miss stories about non-OEM pads, I don’t track my car, and brake dust aside like OEM brake feel.

Yes. Replace the rotors with each service. I run Zimmerman rotors and either BMW or TRW pads.

I’ve been getting r1 concepts after the oem rotors warped, never had a problem since.

I'm using Zimmerman rotors and Textar pads. 11k miles and no complaints so far.

Can’t go wrong with Zimmerman blanks and OEM pads.

Running Zimmerman rotors with Porterfield R4S pads on mine. Brake dust is considerably less than the stock set up.

I have etc red and they work, but I used Zimmerman rotors and never again. Don't go cheap

I personally have had a bad experience with r1 brakes two different times on two different cars. Not saying they're bad just won't buy again. Rotors warped almost immediately both times. New pads and rotors on both cars.