Water pump OEM Toyota or Pierburg

Pierburg Water pump

Pierburg is the OEM maker of the BMW water pump. Spending the extra for the BMW is ridiculous when they are 100% the same exact same pump from the same company from the same factory.

Pros: OEM quality, same as BMW
Cons: BMW overpriced
Vehicle: BMW
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Pierburg Water pump

I'm working on adapting these water pumps to a variety of older engines. This one will be going on a Chevy LSx. The pumps support two different control schemes; one via PWM (no feedback) and one via LIN. I will be working on reversing the LIN communications and building a more sophisticated controller soon.

Pros: supports PWM and LIN
Cons: reversing LIN communications
Vehicle: Chevrolet
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
OEM Toyota Water pump

Over the weekend this is how I did the water pump. I didn't have 2 hydraulic jacks, so I had to come up with some other idea. When I took out the water pump, I think the seal was starting to leak. Cleaned up area and reinstalled with new water pump.

Pros: new water pump installed
Cons: seal was starting leak
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Pierburg Water pump

It happens. I’ve had maybe 3-4 do this out of probably 300 we’ve changed at the shop. Once was a pierburg but the rest were autozone duralast etc.

Pros: warranty may cover labor
Cons: pump may fail quickly
Vehicle: BMW
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
OEM Toyota Water pump

That looks like the water pump but I can be wrong. Also, there is no dipstick for the transmission anymore. Depending on the engine, there is a drain bolt on the side of the transmission on the driver side I believe near the drivetrain.

How many miles do you have? Its probably time to change the water pump if it's making noise and if it is, it needs to be replaced before it causes a whole world of hurt to your wallet.

Cons: making noise
Vehicle: Toyota Camry
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Pierburg Water pump
Ok-Till-8905
  • Overheating:
Rating 2.0

I picked the pierburg for all aluminum casing and impeller. They were both about the same price last time I needed to get one. Note that the pierburg failed at not even 10k miles. I replaced with another pierburg chalking it up to bad luck. The only advantage I can think of with the pierburg is the fact that you can torque down the hoses that use clamps and not have to worry about cracking the housing. But in reality doubtful that is a risk. Also it won’t be in service long enough to get brittle enough to matter.

Pros: all aluminum casing, torque down hoses
Cons: failed prematurely
Vehicle: BMW
Mileage: 10000 km
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
1 2 3 4 5 6

Write your review

Help others - share your experience with this part.

Other comparisons
Loading...