Tires Toyo or OEM Subaru

I have them but a different size. No complaints, smooth, relatively quiet. the Toyo is the more road oriented of the three, and in my case, notably lighter. But I have also taken it to Moab and through some snow wheeling and they’ve been good.

I have the AT3 in 35x11.5 on my 2dr and like them. Good wet, good dry, good snow, etc etc. No negatives to me.

I had these tires on my Audi S5 and they were great in the winter. They have a decent speed rating for a winter tire as well.

Toyo AT3 265/70R18 P load. They're incredibly light.

I tried Toyo snow and ice once and they were probably the best snow & ice tires I’ve ever had.

I put TOYO Observe G3-Ice on my Tacoma last winter. I live in the middle of nowhere on the other side of the country and they were great.

Toyo Observes have the best traction on snow and ice of any non-studded tire. They're impregnated with crushed walnut shells, which act as mini studs. As a result they're noisy on dry pavement. But if traction is your top priority they can't be beat.

The OEM Toyo A36 tires on my car started cracking badly at just 39,600 miles. After driving just 12 miles on the new Pirellis, here’s my honest take:

They are NOT any quieter than the Toyos.

I’m hearing pretty much the same road noise I had with the OEMs.

Even expensive tires can be cheap sometimes depending on how they were manufactured. I got a soft tire once and it wore the treads down super fast on just one tire. I rotated them multiple times and it was always the same tire wearing down.

It was a Toyo Geomancer, the tires were fine and looked nice but that one tire was definitely defective.

I'm not sure if it's luck or they just suck, but within 6k miles of owning my mazda, I've had 2 toyo tires with sidewall problems. I never had any issues on my Michelins