Tires Toyo or Maxxis

I would lean towards Toyo OC AT3 EV (SL). There is more user data available for it, showing equal or nearly equal efficiency result compared to factory Pirelli Scorpion AT Plus.

I have the Toyos. They are great. Would buy again.

My truck is sitting on Toyo Open Country A/T 265/75r17, equivalent to a 32 I believe. Would be 265/80r for a 16 inch wheel. I really like these tires, I have no complaints so far.

Finally decided to ignore this sub entirely and went toyo open country H/Ts and couldn't be happier (beside catching 2 screws within 4 months) Previously had toyo oc A/T and noticed 0 downside in performance on and off road. Wayyy better than m/t s I've run in the past.

I love mine... surprisingly quiet and excellent wet weather gription

Just picked up those same Toyos, love em so far. A little road noise, performs well in bad conditions

The OEM Toyo A36 tires on my car started cracking badly at just 39,600 miles. After driving just 12 miles on the new Pirellis, here’s my honest take:

They are NOT any quieter than the Toyos.

I’m hearing pretty much the same road noise I had with the OEMs.

I ran these on my ‘19 tundra for 55k miles, they were still in decent condition but had a little dry rot and eventually got a massive puncture so I just upgraded to 35’s Toyo open country R/T trail tires

Maxxis have become worse and worse in my experience. I switched to Conti tires, they are soooo much better.

This is one of the reasons I stopped buying Maxxis tires. Really, all tires will do it to a certain degree but Maxxis seem to be the worse IMO.