Tires Pirelli or OEM Subaru

Before my 22 Tiguan SE R Line died from oil issues I put 4 new Pirelli AS Plus 3 tires from Mavis Tire. I liked the tires for the time I had them before October when I got rid of the car.

Pirelli Scorpion AS Plus 3 has been fantastic on my Tiguan as well as my CX5

My Pirelli Scorpios lasted 75k miles. Best tires I ever had. Bought second set

My 2021 SEL has Pirelli Scorpions and they've been great in the heavy downpours we seem to get more often here on the east coast.

Pirelli ok din po. Hindi maingay at makapit sa rain.

The sipes on the Pirelli tire are not full depth. I found that out when I had a set of AS2s. Great for initial testing and reviews, however, after they wear out, they basically become summer tires. Just something to consider.

If you drive conservatively, they might last. If you drive a performance/sports car and you like to drive like you have a pulse, then they won’t last very long, you’ll want more than they can provide, and they love to squeal like a pig.

I know this is an old thread, but I looked up this issue because I just got new tires put on the Tesla Model Y Performance. I am having a very similar issue so I thought I'd look it up. Ironically, the tires I'm having questions about are the Pirelli P Zero AS Plus 3s.

Michelin's. You already know the Pirelli's don't last. The next set won't be any better (speaking from experience).

Just got the Michelins put on this morning. I got 32,000 on the Pirelli’s and could have gotten a few more had I been better at rotating, no complaints on wear but they suuuuuuck in snow.