Tires OEM BMW or Goodyear

We had Goodyear Assurance TripleTreds on our Outback - outstanding traction in rain and snow/slush.

Goodyear Eagle GT, 235/40-18 Rides rough, not too bad noise wise, handles great on dry and wet. Gives good feedback and confidence in corners. I've got about 19k miles on them now, they still have about 30 to 40% tread left. I'm an aggressive driver.

I'm running the same tires I always have -- the ones that came stock on the car -- goodyear eagle F1s -- that I have loved forever and never had problems with...

Better tires like my Goodyear Eagle Gts have features like side walls to protect my rims from curb rash.

These tires are AMAZING! I still run a set on my R32.

I run 225/60/16 Goodyear Ultragrip Ice tires, and I have to say that the Eurovan is extremely capable in heavy snow with these tires.

I got two Goodyear Allegra FuelMax tires for the front of my Jetta before driving to Vancouver and they handled superbly in the rain we encountered every day on the road! I like to drive enthusiastically and they kept up just fine.

I have Goodyear Assurance Fuel Max, seem decent and capable in mild snow and slush. quiet too.

Asymmetric 2's, not the A/S version. I've driven the A/S version in rain and was underwhelmed with those too. At least in heavy rain, I wouldn't want them--that's based on only one experience, but they were at least 8/32's and were not impressive.

I have Eagle F1's on my 986 and am totally underwhelmed.