Tires MICHELIN or Toyo

PartReview Score

Rank #1 in ranking

6096

2256

266

224

2747

4.2

Grip

4.3

Noise

3.6

Ride comfort

4.0

Owners' choice:

PR Score

Ranking

Votes

Reviews

Average rating

Properties

Car

PartReview Score

Rank #11 in ranking

843

360

497

3.8

Grip

3.7

Noise

3.6

Ride comfort

3.9

Owners' choice:

Reviews

All

MICHELIN

Toyo

Toyo › Tires

Realr1 17 Jan 2026, 01:31

Grip:
Ride comfort:

Rating 4.0

I have the Toyo open country atiii on my ‘21 sport, and they handle the socal freeways pretty good for commuting and have been great in the rain we had recently. I did drop about 5-10mpg on ny mpg average.

Pros: handle freeways pretty good, great in rain

Cons: drop in mpg

MICHELIN › Tires

RedSky2727 16 Jan 2026, 23:33

Grip:

Rating 5.0

Putting Cross Climate 2’s on was one of the best decisions ever. Wet, dry, snow or sun… doesn’t matter - these tires continue to impress.

Pros: impressive in all conditions

Vehicle: Jeep Grand Cherokee

MICHELIN › Tires

Ok_Tell_2420 16 Jan 2026, 22:44

Noise:
Ride comfort:

Rating 4.0

I like Michelin Primacy for quiet ride

Pros: quiet ride

MICHELIN › Tires

arctic-993 16 Jan 2026, 21:26

Grip:

Rating 5.0

One thing to note, we absolutely love the Michelin Defenders.

Pros: absolutely love them

Toyo › Tires

rc_sneex 16 Jan 2026, 20:41

Grip:

Rating 4.0

22” Toyo Celsius A/S in urban New England; ~80% of my driving is short trips in city or light traffic. I got about 25k out of my last set.

Mileage: 40233 km

Toyo › Tires

IJHjelle 16 Jan 2026, 18:24

Grip:
Ride comfort:

Rating 5.0

TOYO CELCIUS SPORT 225/55R17 101V XL

not the standard answer but been really really happy with theseo

Pros: really really happy

MICHELIN › Tires

viejobbia 16 Jan 2026, 17:29

Grip:
Ride comfort:

Rating 5.0

It handles Midwest winters way better than the four options you listed, lasts longer (80k warranty), and feels more planted on heavier SUVs.

Pros: better winter handling, lasts longer

Vehicle: Jeep Grand Cherokee

MICHELIN › Tires

Spatula_of_Justice1 16 Jan 2026, 16:22

Grip:
Ride comfort:

Rating 5.0

Michelin Defender 2 is a wonderful tire

Pros: wonderful tire

MICHELIN › Tires

chdev69 5 Jan 2026, 17:50

Noise:

Rating 3.0

Have quite a bit of feedback on the wheel despite road force balancing and wondering if the “normal” values might help.

Cons: feedback on the wheel

Vehicle: Audi Q5

MICHELIN › Tires

NotABkr_IJustCkALot 30 Dec 2025, 20:14

Grip:

Rating 2.0

I put Michelin Pilot AS4s on my Subaru WRX in about Nov 2022. They were great for that winter. Since they're "ultra high performance all-weather" tires, I just planned on running them year-round. Come next winter, though - they were legit dangerous.

Pros: great for one winter

Cons: dangerous next winter

Vehicle: Subaru