Tires MICHELIN or Pirelli

Just purchased a set of Michelin CROSSCLIMATE 2 225/45R18 for Minnesota winters for my 2019. One of the best rated tires in Consumer Reports.

Needed to replace tires, got Pirelli P7 Plus 3, 225 / 45 R18. Anyone is looking for a quieter ride, I'm really pleased with these tires. Road noise significantly reduced from the Vredestein Quadtrack Pro that came on the car. Very happy with corning, road holding, rain.

Costco has served me well. Bought a set of Michelins a few months ago. Great tires, but I caught a nail near the sidewall. Costco ordered a new tire and replaced it for free.

I was thinking of getting the Michelin Pilot A/S on my TSportline 20x10 TSS wheels but went with the Conti ExtremeContact DWS 06 plus.

No other tire beats a Michelin for smoother ride. After multiple sets starting from PS AS1, best All season tire money can buy.

I ended up replacing with the Michelin Pilot Sport All Season 4. I was happy to find that the ride quality significantly improved after this.

I love the CrossClimate2 but would try the Weatherpeak next on 2020 RAV4 Hybrid. Only con I've noted with the CC2 is that the gas mileage has dropped like 5-10% though that could be temporarily as the tires break in, and the OEM Dunlop are low rolling resistance tires with poor grip/high noise.

The P Zero All-Season may be your best bet if you're set on all-seasons. They were fine when I had one of the previous scorpion AS iterations on my E53, seemed to be a good value.

Only other thing I'm seeing available is discount tire with a Nitto NT420V. I'd take the Pirelli over that.

Have experience with Kumho vs Michelin pilots 4s.

Similar price (ish). Kumho are rubbish. Completely changed the handling of the car for the better when I went on the pilots.

You wont get mileage though.

I only put michelins on mine anymore. They are the best tires made, the worst set I ever owned were Pirellis that lasted legit 12k miles and became unbearably loud.