Tires Falken or OEM BMW

Wildpeaks over all the others. I have hundreds of thousands of miles experience with all three and the Falkens are by far the best in all conditions and remain consistent over the life of tread. The KOs will get louder and offer less traction the more miles you put on them, the Toyos, in my experience don't last that long at all. My WPs have stayed relatively quiet and continued to offer the same traction on/offroad throughout their life, I've also been getting roughly 70-80k miles out of them before even considering replacing them.

The downside to the Falkens is that they're very heavy compared to the others. I noticed a sizeable drop in MPG for sure.

My work truck has been on Falken tires since a few months before I got it 25,000 miles ago. I have never had any issues with stopping distance and the tread is still a 7 on the most worn of the four. I'd say they aren't so bad

Falken Wildpeak a/t Trail unless you never go off-road or have to deal with bad weather.

Put AT4Ws on my JKRR last spring and have been very happy. Great grip off road, quiet and stable in the highway. No issues in rain. Only one drive in a little snow so far, but good there, too.

I have the wild peak 4’s (35’s) and love them … mileage dropped about 2-3 mpg … not to loud on street and so far good in rain and great offroad

I just put at4’s on my JLUS - just as quiet as the factory AT’s and feel the same on the freeway - feel grippier on dry pavement than stock, haven’t had a chance to try them in the rain yet.

I’ve been really happy the AT3’s I got year before last, they perform admirably offroad and in snow, and they are great on the highway to boot

I’ve had the falken at3’s for the last 4 years. Amazing tires that have treated me very well. Great in all conditions with good throttle control and very good wet weather grip compared to the KO2’s I had before.

Tbh you get what you pay for. Not great. There’s others that make a better all season tire then falk and at the same price. But if you don’t mind a little higher I’d look at something like the cross climates Michelin has or the cooper endura max or the Nokian wr. Nokians are amazing but suffer from issues in really hot weather. I’d get the cooper endura for Ohio. Won’t disappoint you either. Amazing in winter and summer

Lol falken tires were bald within 3000 miles, continentals have almost 12k and still look new.