Thermostat Mahle or OEM Nissan

OEM Nissan Thermostat
burn3344
  • Overheating:
Rating 5.0

I’ve had so many replacements fail in all my Nissans over the years that I just get an oem one from a dealer. Never had an oem one shit out yet.

Pros: OEM reliable, no failures
Vehicle: Nissan
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Mahle Thermostat
analogrelease
  • Overheating:
Rating 4.0

Mahle is the OE replacement for the thermostat, the Chrysler logo is on the part but sanded down. Autozone sells them with PT# TI23695 I just replaced mine last weekend.

Pros: OE replacement, Chrysler logo
Part number: TI23695
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
OEM Nissan Thermostat

Since going with the OEM thermostat, my temp gauge has stayed pinned just below the middle of the gauge, even towing campers and heavy loads on hot days.

Pros: stable temperature, handles heavy loads
Vehicle: Nissan
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Mahle Thermostat
Ill_Slice_7084
  • Slow warm-up:
  • Cabin heat:
Rating 3.0

Thermostat and temp sensor were just replaced with OE Mahle/Behr. P0128 showed up after car didn’t get up to temp. Heat is slightly affected until reaches operating temp.

Cons: car didn’t get up to temp
Vehicle: BMW
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Mahle Thermostat
kemosabe6296
  • Cabin heat:
Rating 3.5

I’ve been using Germany-made Mahle thermostat for years. Now it throws a code that the heater doesn’t work (so it won’t open electrically, but mechanically it is working just fine), but no leaks.

Pros: mechanically working, no leaks
Cons: throws heater code
Vehicle: BMW
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Mahle Thermostat
PsEuDoAnOnYmOuS47
  • Slow warm-up:
  • Overheating:
  • Cabin heat:
Rating 1.0

1st Mahle. The engine only reaches up to 65 degrees and it drops further if I drive under 2000RPMs on highway for example or turn on the heating.

Cons: engine underheats, temperature drops
Vehicle: BMW
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Mahle Thermostat
PsEuDoAnOnYmOuS47
  • Slow warm-up:
  • Cabin heat:
Rating 1.0

car in winter cant even reach optimal temperature in idle, reaches optimal temperature only uphills on RPMS higher thatn 2500

Cons: cannot reach optimal temp idle
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Mahle Thermostat
Jucebox85
  • Slow warm-up:
Rating 1.0

In regards to replacing the thermostat, Id stay away from Mahle/Behr. I just ran through two that stuck open, so far the Borg and Warner from FCP can actually hold temp @ -19C, which the Mahles could not at -10C.

Pros: can actually hold temp
Cons: stuck open, could not
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
1 2 3 4

Write your review

Help others - share your experience with this part.

Other comparisons
Loading...