Windshield OEM BMW or Pilkington

Pilkington Windshield
SaintEyegor
  • Chips/cracks:
Rating 4.0

If you can, avoid using Subaru glass for the replacement. I replaced mine with a pilkington windshield and it isn’t as sensitive to cracks spreading.

Pros: less sensitive to cracks
Cons: Subaru glass sensitive
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Pilkington Windshield

Toyota used an acoustic windshield on the 2006-2009 refresh. If you own an earlier model it can be installed as an upgrade. You can also get a shaded windshield - I asked Safelite to see if that was an option. They installed a Pilkington.

Pros: acoustic windshield upgrade
Vehicle: Toyota Prius
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
OEM BMW Windshield
Mattka24
  • Chips/cracks:
Rating 4.0

My Model S plan went from $15->$20 monthly and I’m keeping it. I had to replace a windshield on my BMW earlier this year at $1300 out of pocket.

Pros: cheaper than out of pocket
Cons: increase in cost
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Pilkington Windshield
dbrmn73
  • Chips/cracks:
Rating 5.0

I have a Pilkington Windshield. Been on the Jeep for over 10yrs now. Went over 8yrs with no chips/cracks. It now has 2 small chips that have not spread in over 2 years.

Pros: long lasting, minimal damage
Cons: now has small chips
Vehicle: Jeep
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Pilkington Windshield
kh04
  • Clarity:
Rating 4.0

Just use Pilkington glass if you have the HUD and you’ll be fine (will need to rotate HUD a bit). Check out my last post if you want to see what incorrect glass for the HUD looks like, and central speaker will also sound worse.

Pros: HUD will be fine
Cons: speaker will sound worse
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
OEM BMW Windshield
99cereal
  • Chips/cracks:
Rating 3.0

2018 BMW F30 318d: Fragile windshields? We’re on the 3rd one already. Oil filter housing was replaced at 125k km due to a cracked coolant passage. OEM unit was plastic and was replaced with a metal one. Wheel speed sensors have been replaced twice already.

Pros: routine maintenance
Cons: fragile windshields
Vehicle: BMW
Mileage: 130000 km
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Pilkington Windshield
MechanicalCheese
  • Clarity:
  • Chips/cracks:
Rating 2.0

I bought mine with an aftermarket replacement pilkington glass already installed - not sure for how long. So it's been on their at least 7 years now and the quality has degraded more than any other car I've had. There are no cracks or major dings but it just has microscopic pitting all over that glares in the right light. I can clean and claybar it to perfection and it's still not great.

Cons: quality degraded, microscopic pitting, glares in light
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
OEM BMW Windshield
Druid17BC
  • Clarity:
  • Chips/cracks:
Rating 1.0

In over 20+ years of owning BMWs, and 35 years of owning other brands, I’ve never had a windshield crack. Then yesterday my 2024 M4 X40i with 7000 miles got hit by a people and bam, not just a chip, it cracked halfway across. Unfortunately, mine is on the driver’s side, right at my eyeline.

Cons: cracked easily, chipped easily
Vehicle: BMW M4
Mileage: 11265 km
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
Pilkington Windshield

It took a month for me to make Safelite to replace my cracked windshield to the new Pilkington.

I have OEM coverage in my insurance policy, so I had to negotiate Pilkington instead of OEM windshield. They approved Pilkington and created an order to Safelite.

Once I came to the appointment, I found they ordered OEM instead and wanted to install OEM. Took the car back and asked them to order Pilkington, rescheduled for 5 days later.

7 days later came and found out they forgot to order one. Offered to install OEM instead. Asked them to order Pilkington and reschedule the appointment.

Another 7 days later came to them again, they said the new windshield is non-oem, asked them to double-check what vendor is exactly. And it was FUYAO. I declined to install fuyao and asked to order the glass I want at past.

7 days later next appointment - they confirmed Pilkington has come, ready to install. Left a car, was told everything will be ready in 3 hours. 1 hour later incoming call from them: “It happened the windshield we’ve got is for previous outback generation, not compatible with yours. Would you like to have FUYAO instead? We already removed your old windshield”. I declined this, I was struggling with them to have Pilkington, and didn’t want to back down. Told them they owe me a loaner car if my is not drivable, and I will wait for my Pilkington glass. 20 minutes later their manager called me and offered me to install FUYAO as a temporary solution, they will order Pilkington and once it will come they’ll replace it. And that I (insurance) will pay only for one glass. So I agreed, they installed the new Fuyao, recalibrated EyeSight (they even left lane-assist enabled). The glass was crystal clear, they cleaned it.

In 10 days Pilkington glass had come, I drove the car to them, they replaced fuyao to Pilkington. The new windshield was not clean as the previous one, and I also doubt they made recalibration one more time (lane keep assist was disabled).

Coming home I found they lose windshield cowling clips, one was absent, the second one was incorrect bigger size and didn’t fit the body hole. They grabbed it from the intake collector resonator mount.

So, overall, I disappointed of their work and organizational quality.

Pros: crystal clear glass
Cons: poor organizational quality
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 23

Write your review

Help others - share your experience with this part.

Other comparisons
Loading...