Tires Toyo or Pirelli

I live in the Midwest so I went for all season tires. Pirelli P-Zero is what I go for. I had them on my last car (9³) and they handle really well in the dry, but have good traction in snow. They lasted about 25,000-30,000mi on the 9³. My G70 is RWD and snow was no problem at all and they’re very grippy. Have only had them about 4,000mi on the G70.

Can’t speak to them on a crosstrek directly, but I have a set on my Xterra. Not terrible in terms of road noise day to day (even at a higher load rating on a heavier vehicle), and great tread life so far. As for grip, they are excellent. They got me through Minnesota’s snowiest winter in recent history last year and aided in getting a lot of my neighbors unstuck too.

I had AT3’s on my trek before I sold it for a truck. Great tires. They were great on muddy back roads in Texas getting to rural stations and were just as good when I moved to Colorado and dealt with snow storms.

Love the Toyo AT3 on my 17 CT. 215/65R15s. For comparison, the Bridgestones were 8lbs heavier per tire and that’s a huge difference in acceleration and wear/tear on the suspension/steering components. Also they are much quieter than Bridgestones.

Currently have a/t 3 on my CT, overall love them, 19k on the tires overall with light to moderate off-road and as well snow storms. They are a bit noiser but once you get used to it, the noise won't bother you. Better traction overall and worth it compared to the stock tires that came on mine. Went mudding over the weekend and they did great

This will not definitely answer your question but I currently have XXX6s with Pirelli P Zero 30s on my 2022 Gen 6 and it fits with plenty of room left over (I am assuming there was no frame dimension change from 2020 to 2022).

I’ve got Pirelli P-Zeros on my RS5 since the previous owner put them on recently before selling and I have to say that they are actually good despite what some people say. I actually felt like they handled better than the PS4S on my fathers old A45 AMG and while it might be down to the car I still am not disappointed.

My subjective experience is that GP 5000 S TR 28 feel great and are light but they're not very durable. I feel like my Pirelli Pro Race TLR 28 last twice as long but feel a tad heavier.

I absolutely hate Pirelli tires. The one time I had them on my 2013 Hatch the car didn’t feel right. It felt like it was way too slick in the rain and turns felt sluggish.

What model of tire did you get I got the Perelli all seasons on my AWD magnum and they SUCK.