Tires Pirelli or Cooper

I had good experience with Pirelli P4 season. I put 75k miles on a 2008 awd ford taurus all highway mileage. No balance issues and even wearing. Worked reasonably well in my northeast pa winters.

I had an e46 with a set of P-Zero Nero's years ago so perhaps things have changed but mine were great, kicked the shit outta those garbage Michelins that were on there

Personally, I’ve never had any issues with any consumer pirelli tire I’ve ran before. Their ice zeros are great on my wrx in winter.

I’m a cheap ass and I run the Walmart Cooper Discoverer A/T’s at 265/75/16 for $145 a tire. Perfectly fine for my driving which sounds similar to yours

The 32" Cooper Discoverer AT3s on our YJ have been great. And they were very affordable.

Running 15x32x11.5 Cooper's on my YJ. I dig em and decently priced.

I put coopers on my last two ats and I loved them.

I have a set of Cooper 225/60/18 snow tires that grip really well, but I don't like the way they drive. The skinniness makes turning feel loose, and it feels like the car is going to flip (though it definitely isn't).

I just bought an F150 with pretty new Pirelli tires. My old one ran Michelins. The Pirellis just don't ride and perform nearly as good.

I am sure Pirelli makes plenty of good tires but I was shocked how terrible the OEM P Zero summer tires were that came on my 2016 mustang. Equivalent summer tires from both Michelin and Continental were quieter, had better grip when hot, had better grip when cold, and performed better in the rain.