Tires Cooper or Achilles

Hands down the Cooper Cobra Instinct out of those listed.

I have a 2017 cx5 gt. I live in Pennsylvania with horrible roads, so I went with cooper discoverer enduramax, and I love them. Performed great in the two snow storms so far.

The cooper tires, just had them installed on my work van, good traction, no noise

Incredible in mud and snow. I have them on an f350 dually. It will literally go anywhere on the jobsite. I also put them on my personal f150 I was so impressed. I've plowed through 3' snow drifts with ease.

Coopers are good tires if you rotate them they literally last forever. I’ve managed to get 80-100,000 good kms out of the discoverer stt pro and st max. Ran AT3s as well and got even more as you don’t really have big lugs to lose anyway.

Put them on my AWD Subaru Assent and with around 8K miles had a 10 inch snow with 12 inch drifts and I drove it in a remote field of snow a good distance and down a remote gravel and paved road with that amount of snow and it was a beast! These tires are quiet and handle really well on my 165 round trip daily commute to work, especially when it's raining....

The "replacement" for these is the Cooper Discoverer Road+Trail AT which is an excellent tire, basically the same as what you have with a few refinements.

I got 50,000 on a set of these and never rotated them. They were howling pretty bad because of it, and totally my fault. I went in to replace them and the tire shop said I had plenty of tread to go farther, I just couldn't stand the howl anymore.

These photos show what happened to two of my 265/75R16 E rated Cooper Discoverer AT3 tires after 4 years and 25k miles. One blew up and one developed a bulge.

I'm disliking mine. Could have been a suspension problem initially. But at 65-75/80 the steering wheel shakes. Still travels straight, but the annoyance of seeing/feeling it shake is terrible.