Alternator OEM KIA or VALEO

OEM KIA Alternator
scbwdt
  • Warning light:
Rating 4.0

I Had a 200k mile 2011 Soul and didn't have any major issues. 3k mile oil change, 3-5 yr battery change, some tire change, alternator replaced at 190k.

Pros: no major issues
Vehicle: Kia Soul
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
VALEO Alternator
Ok-Delivery216
  • Warning light:
Rating 5.0

I installed the Valeo alternator that I got from FCP Euro and everything works now. The rebuilt Valeo was $200 less expensive than the Valeo that O’Reilly’s had in their computer but couldn’t order themselves. Also it was immaculate. It was a true rebuild and looked brand new in every way. It was $400.

Pros: immaculate, brand new
Cons: expensive
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
OEM KIA Alternator

I have a 2013 Soul !. Got it about 2 years ago. Very reliable, only had one issue and that was the alternator going out on me a few weeks ago. 182k miles on it. It doesn\u2019t consume oil at the same pace others mention. It does currently idle a little rough, but Not terribly.

Pros: very reliable
Cons: rough idle
Vehicle: Kia Soul
Mileage: 182000 km
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
VALEO Alternator

A brand new Valeo (439317) alternator is $209 on Rockauto and they can be swapped in an hour or two.

Pros: easy to swap
Part number: 439317
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
VALEO Alternator

I then ordered a Valeo from Bimmerworld which arrived seized. Finally ordered the same Valeo from RockAuto (for less money, too) which has been working great so far.

Pros: working great
Cons: arrived seized
Part number: 43917
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
OEM KIA Alternator
rneuf
  • Warning light:
  • Lights:
Rating 4.0

The alternator on my 2019 Forte failed.

I bought a used one with 20k miles on it, an new idler and tensioner pulley for around $350. Installed it all myself.

Pros: bought used alternator
Cons: alternator failed
Vehicle: Kia
Mileage: 32187 km
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
VALEO Alternator

mine is a Valeo alternator and though you are probably correct, this is the original alternator (22 years old) and it will probably get me through another few years at least.

Pros: working for now
Cons: temporary fix
Comment
Is this review helpful?
source
1 2 3 4 5 6

Write your review

Help others - share your experience with this part.

Other comparisons
Loading...